5 Most Unexpected FA Cup Shocks in Everton's History
Book a room
Or call0151 236 0166
For exclusive offers

5 of the Most Unexpected FA Cup Shocks in Everton’s History

Diminishing reputation or otherwise, the FA Cup is stunning and superb, memorable and mysterious but, most importantly, it is shocking. The FA Cup makes one think of David vs Goliath, that’s if David was Shrewsbury Town and Goliath was Everton and the entire spectacle was set on a morbid afternoon in January.

From glutenous extravaganzas to torturous trouncing’s and marksman milkmen, the FA Cup is known for surprises, superlatives and super shocking moments.

So, with Everton’s latest FA Cup defeat in mind, we thought we’d look back at some of the most unexpected FA Cup shocks in Everton’s history.

Shrewsbury Town 2-1 Everton (2003)


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Shrewsbury Town FC (@shrewsburytown) on

In 2003, Shrewsbury Town were in the dungeons of the fourth tier when they faced Premier League opposition in Everton; we mean, what could possibly go wrong. The answer: absolutely everything.

Nigel Jenson was the Shrews hero that day as he scored twice to cement Everton’s place on every countdown ever of the greatest FA Cup shocks.

Interestingly, Steve Jagielka – older brother of future Everton captain Phil – was an 81 minute substitute for Shrewsbury Town that day.

Manchester United 0-0 Everton (2-4) (2009)

Now, some may say that this score barely constitutes a shock. And for those who have seen their team win actual trophies, they’d be correct. However, to those born after 1995, this win was unexpected, shocking even.

Everton had grounded out 120 minutes of absolute boredom at Wembley and seemed simply honoured to be a part of Manchester United’s eventual win. But penalties are anyone’s, everyone knows that.

That said, when Everton’s opening pen was smashed over the bar many Evertonian’s began sneaking towards the tube station. One Evertonian famously stormed out and missed the entire shootout just metres away from his Wembley seat.

However, because of Tim Howards’ heroics and Berbatov’s nonchalance, Everton managed an FA Cup shock that was so shocking even they were shocked.

Everton 0-1 Oldham (2008)

A team made up of Stefan Wessels and James McFadden was always bound to lose to Oldham in 2008; and that is what they did.

John Sheridan’s Oldham stunned Everton in what was a prime example of both David Moyes’ ineptitude and the enchantment of the FA Cup.

Everton 1-0 Liverpool (2009)

This Merseyside Derby is as famous for an impromptu Tic Tac commercial as it is for Dan Gosling’s extra time winner.

What was so astounding about this FA Cup match was that Everton both deserved to win, and then did in the most Liverpool way ever.

Even though those watching at home may have missed the goal – instead, they watched a bunch of Tic Tac’s clowning around – those inside Goodison Park were sent apoplectic as Everton closed out the match.

Whether you’ve forgiven him for leaving Everton or not, Dan Gosling’s name is synonymous with the FA Cup.

Everton 0-3 Tranmere (2001)

This FA Cup palaver was more of an embarrassment than a shock. John Aldridge’s (sorry to make it worse) side made the journey across the River Mersey and heaped FA Cup humiliation on Walter Smith.

Names such as Aldridge and Smith, and scores such as 3-0 show just how dark those days were. However, Tranmere’s win must go down as one of the most unexpected FA Cup shocks in Everton’s history.

The Dixie Dean Hotel

The Dixie Dean Hotel is set to complete Liverpool’s upcoming Football Quarter. The luxury venue is to take pride and place opposite the now famous Shankly Hotel, which celebrates the existence of Liverpool’s legendary leader.

The unique hotel – unlike anything seen before – is to provide Evertonian’s with an unrivalled experience, perfect for overnights stays, watching the match and basking in and enjoying unseen memorabilia.

To keep up with the latest news and developments, head over to our Facebook page or check back to the blog soon. And, while your there, why don’t you see if any of our FA Cup shocks feature on our Everton Quiz.

Related news

Blog | 10th June 2019

The Lionesses to Look Out For at the Women’s World Cup

Much has been made of England’s supposed transition from perennial newbies to World Cup favourites. The women’s game...

Blog | 30th May 2019

Opening Date Set for Dixie Dean Hotel in Liverpool

We’re excited to announce that the date is set for the grand Dixie Dean Hotel opening. Officially taking place...

Blog | 22nd May 2019

World Football Transfers: The Most Controversial Transfer Deals

With the 2019 summer transfer window well and truly open until 8 August, we thought we’d take a look...

Blog | 22nd November 2018

The 7 Best Everton Matches Ever

Emblazoned on the ironclad paneling that surrounds Goodison is a maxim that epitomises an array of Everton matches....

Blog | 9th October 2018

Everton FC: Discover Some Fascinating Goodison Park History

Goodison Park, or The Grand Old Lady as it’s affectionately known, has been the home of the Toffees...

Bar & Restaurant Blog | 8th September 2019

The Dixie Dean Hotel Launches the No.9 Bar and Restaurant Menu

Celebrate Autumn with some absolutely delicious food from the new No.9 Bar and Restaurant menu. There are plenty...

Blog | 2nd September 2019

Introducing the Football Quarter Podcast with David Fehily and Chris Shankly

The season is here again and while you already know about the giants of football podcasting: Guardian Football...

Blog | 27th August 2019

Alan Ball: The Ball of Fire

Here at the Dixie Dean Hotel we like to celebrate our heroes. This article is both a precursor...



Stay up to date

Let’s get social

What would you like to book?

We offer luxury rooms and unforgettable dining experiences

Book a room

Book a table

Book direct for the best price guaranteed

With the Signature Price Promise you won't find our rooms cheaper anywhere else*





Please select the required amount of guests

For groups of 7 or more please contact us on
0151 236 0166